India is a large and most diverse nation with two inimical neighbours.
India’s myriad problems provide innumerable opportunities for the belligerent adversaries to exploit in the grey zone.
The increased radicalisation in the neighbourhood has further opened up new grey spaces.
Grey zone tactics is being followed both by China and Pakistan using different means.
Pakistan.
Pakistan is using the low-cost option of grey zone tactics against India by promoting violent extremist groups.
These non-state actor groups get funding and training in Pakistan, to carry out irregular warfare against India.
The spectrum of anti-India grey zone warfare emanating from Pakistan is fairly wide ranging from disinformation and incitement to terrorism.
The grey zone activities of Pakistan include propaganda, false narratives, cyber warfare, and encouraging internal dissent to terrorism, to undermine the Indian national security.
China.
China is the master of grey zone operations.
This type of warfare is embedded in her philosophy, strategic thoughts and doctrines.
China has further mastered the art of converting and using anything and everything into a weapon for grey zone warfare.
China practices its famous three-warfare strategy, encompasses non-kinetic means like psychology, media and law warfare, to achieve political ends.
China has been using psychological warfare and coercion against India with the aim to subdue India without fighting.
Dealing Strategy.
India a large democratic and bureaucratic state is considered to be a weak spot for grey zone operations.
It will lose out if does not adapt to the changing nature of warfare.
India must prepare to deter China and Pakistan from extreme forms of grey zone aggression.
An important part of any grey zone response strategy is to undertake institutional reform.
These organisational and structural reforms, need to be embedded in the current structures, in a phased manner without causing too much of turbulence.
A word of caution that a change for the sake of change due to peer pressure needs to be avoided.
The change should be based on factors like our threat perception, technological threshold, economic conditions and geo-political environment.
India, must develop framework of strategic deterrence to deal with grey zone warfare.
More coming up on this subject
Comments and value additions are most welcome
For regular updates please register here –
I have always wondered. Why can’t India do to Pakistan what Pakistan is doing to India? China of course is a different ball game.